A Federal High Court in Abuja on Friday ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to restore the Peoples Democratic Party’s (PDP) governorship candidate in Ogun State, Mr Oladipupo Adebutu, to the list of candidates for the 2027 governorship election within 24 hours.
Justice Peter Lifu issued the order in a judgment in a suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/2573/2026 and filed by Adebutu against INEC.
The trial judge held that the commission had no power to unilaterally remove the name of a validly nominated candidate by a political party without the leave of court.
The judge held that INEC’s action was unconstitutional, unlawful and was of no effect.
He further declared that it is only the Federal High Court or a state’s high court that has the power to declare the candidate of a political candidate invalid and not INEC.
He held that INEC breached Adebutu’s right to fair hearing before unilaterally removing his name from the list.
Recall that the PDP and Adebutu had on October 22, filed the suit following the removal of Adebutu’s name from the list of contestants of the governorship seat in Ogun.
The plaintiffs sued INEC as the sole defendant in the suit filed by their lawyer, Mr Ahmed Raji.
The plaintiffs, who sought six questions for determination, prayed the court for 11 reliefs.
They sought an order setting aside the commission’s decision to omit, remove or refuse to publish Adebutu’s name in the final list of candidates published on October 10 for denial of a fair hearing and violation of the provisions of Section 29 and Section 32 of the Electoral Act, 2026.
They also sought an order directing or compelling “the defendant to, within twenty-four (24) hours of the order/orders of this honourable court, include and/or publish the name of the 2nd plaintiff as the 1st plaintiff’s governorship candidate for Ogun State in the forthcoming 2027 general election,” among other reliefs.
The judge, who dismissed the preliminary objection filed by INEC, declared that the suit was competent and that the exclusion of Adebutu’s name was unlawful, unconstitutional and of no effect.
“I have carefully assessed the originating summons and I see that it bears the name of the senior counsel and was signed by him. It also has the names of other counsels in the law firm,” the judge said.
In the substantive suit, Judge Lifu said the 2nd plaintiff (Adebutu), stated that he sought the office of the Governor of Ogun State in 2019 and he was the 2023 governorship candidate.
He added that he participated in the primary for the 2027 poll, and that on August 29, 2026, the party published his name, and there was no challenge.
“That in October, when INEC published the names of candidates, it was discovered that his name was not included, and that he had not withdrawn from the race. That on October 14 the PDP and national secretary wrote INEC to reverse this but to no avail.”
The judge said INEC claimed that the Commission was bound to obey the provisions of the Electoral Act.
He said one Umar Bature testified as PW1 while Mustapa Mohammed testified as DW1.
In his testimony, Bature said he was the national organising secretary of the first plaintiff and responsible for the registration of new members and for the party’s register.
He said the list of party members was submitted to INEC within the prescribed time in a flash drive and it contained the name of the second plaintiff, the Ogun PDP governorship candidate.
He also argued that Adebutu’s membership of the PDP had never been in doubt, noting that he was the first to register as a member on February 24, 2026.
Bature maintained that the removal of their candidate was not in line with any law and urged the court to order INEC to publish his name.
He pointed out that the party submitted the list of all its members on April 22, 2026, with a total number of over 30, 000.
The judge said DW1, Mustapha, testified that he was the programme analyst at INEC, noting that he supervised the exercise by PW1.
He told the court that the PDP submitted the list of its members in hard copy and a flash drive.
The DW1 said before the publication of the final list of candidates, the department conducted a search and discovered that the name of Adebutu was not on the list but the name of his deputy was on the list.
The judge said, under cross examination, DW1 admitted that he was not the one that received the flash drive from the PDP, and that he would not know what was submitted.
The issues for determination according to the court are, whether the plaintiffs’ right to fair hearing was breached; whether INEC has the power to unilaterally disqualify Adebutu, and whether the defendant can remove the name of the candidate, among others.
On issue one, the judge held that the right to fair hearing was fundamental in Nigeria’s jurisprudence adding that, “It is a judicial or administrative hearing conducted by due process.
“Therefore, before a decision is taken over a person, such a person must be afforded the right to fair hearing.”
The judge held that the plaintiff’s right to fair hearing was breached by INEC and that, “When a right is vested in a person, such right cannot be taken away without hearing from the person.
“Adebutu was not accorded the right to be heard before INEC took the decision. Therefore, the right to fair hearing of the plaintiff is breached,” the court held.
On the second issue, the judge said the first plaintiff noted that the second plaintiff was duly nominated by the party and his name forwarded to the defendant.
“I have taken a cursory look at the judgment of the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court did not give INEC the power to start omitting or removing names of members from a party.
“INEC does not have the power to remove names or disqualify any candidate on its own. The power to disqualify a candidate after the name has been forwarded resides with the Federal High Court or State High Court.
“The commission lacks the power to disqualify any candidate. Even if INEC believes that the name of a candidate was omitted, the commission must approach the court that has the power to remove the name.
“The power to nominate a candidate for an election exclusively belongs to a political party, and the exercise of that power is within a party.
“A court has no power to nominate a candidate. That has been the position of the law. The effect of the above is that no authority can nominate a candidate or remove it,” the court said.
He added: “All issues such as nomination of candidates, publications, are all pre-election matters. Adebutu was declared the winner of the primary election on May 24. INEC did not raise any issue.
“As far as I know, no person filed any suit to challenge Adebutu 14 days after the conduct of the poll. It was baffling that INEC waited until August. This court has established that INEC lacks the power to disqualify any candidate.
“INEC should have approached the court to disqualify the candidate but it waited until after four months to take the action. This, to me, is an afterthought.
“If this is not resolved, there will be a day that INEC will disqualify a candidate a day to election. This must not be allowed. This would be an absurdity”.
He said, the law provides that, the list of members are made available not later than 21 days before the election and that, “It is only members whose names are contained that can participate in an election and the plaintiffs said Adebutu participated and that his name is in the list.
“INEC should have raised the issue that Adebutu did not participate in its monitoring reports. The action of INEC makes it plausible that the name of the second plaintiff was contained in the list and that his serial number is 1536”.
Lifu noted that the first Defendant’s witness said the name of Adebutu was not in the flash drive and later turned to say he was not the one that received the flash drive.
“The law is trite that failure to call a material or vital witness is fatal to the case of the defendant,” the judge held and consequently resolved the issue in favour of the plaintiff.
Justice Lifu stated, “Consequently, the case of the plaintiff succeeds and is meritorious. The defendant acted ultra vires. INEC has no power, either administratively or otherwise, to remove a name if a candidate was validly nominated. The removal is unlawful, unconstitutional and of no effect.”
The Court declared that by virtue of the Electoral Act, INEC was bound to publish Adebutu’s name and ordered INEC to rectify the list published on October 10, 2026, to reflect Adebutu’s name.
The court also declared that INEC could not pronounce the result of the 2027 governorship election without the participation of the plaintiffs, or “the election shall be of no effect and unconstitutional.”
With NAN and Tribune reports




















































